AGRIFISH agreement: EU member states ignore facts and science - active fishing for critically endangered eel is not banned

CCB • December 13, 2022

With no support in facts or science [1], the EU fisheries ministers have decided to continue chasing the critically endangered eel. The EU Member States actively opposed to sensible proposals to further the survival of European eel and the same Member States must now go to the Montreal COP15 and declare that “we should create a shared future for all life on earth – except for eel”.

Today the Fisheries Council decided [2] to continue targeting the critically endangered eel. The EU Commission proposed a consecutive six-month ban of fishing but this was aggressively opposed by countries led by France, Sweden, Denmark and Spain. The Commissioner called out the Member States as being dishonest in their approach, considering that they have during the past year written and spoken about further measures to protect the eel multiple times. Now, when a proposal to actually safeguard migration of adult eels as well as recently born eels was on the table, they shoot it down.


The original proposal was watered down to be a three plus three-month ban but with options for derogation and opening up the chance for Member States to place the closure period when it has little or no impact.  The Member States acted with no support in science and instead, against facts and figures presented over 20 years, pushed forward another massive loophole to continue active fishing on this critically endangered species.

 

“It is as if they intentionally wants to kill off the last eels by both allowing fishing to continue and at the same time not doing anything to improve eel habitats and migration routes. Most member states cannot even close their own internal waters for recreational fishing, a fishing for fun on an endangered species, even though anglers support such a ban!” says Nils Höglund, CCB Fisheries Policy Officer. He continues: “It is now difficult to take these countries statements and words seriously in anything related to biodiversity protection. We must applaud the Commission for trying and for pressuring the Member States, knowing that even the proposal for a 6-month ban was not enough but at least something.”


FURTHER INFORMATION:


[1]
ICES Advice on European eel (3 November 2022).


[2] The full outcome of the Agrifish council is available here:


By CCB • November 13, 2026
From dam removals in Finland to eelgrass returning in the Stockholm archipelago, restoration in the Baltic Sea is already under way. At a side event alongside the HELCOM Ministerial Meeting in Warsaw on 4 November, WWF and Coalition Clean Baltic (CCB) brought together government officials, farmers, volunteers and civil-society youth representatives to discuss how these local successes can turn into recovery of the entire Baltic Sea region. The event, “Restoring the Baltic Sea: From Local Successes to Regional Recovery” , took place on the same day that ministers ended their meeting without a Ministerial Declaration – leaving the HELCOM Regional Action Plan for Benthic Habitat Restoration unadopted. WWF and CCB hope the plan will be adopted in spring 2027. The event showed why it matters. Opening the event, Mirosław Proppé, CEO of WWF Poland , pointed to WWF’s latest Living Planet Report , which shows that wildlife populations continue to decline, including in the ocean. In our sea, Baltic cod is a stark example of a depleted population. But the report also offers hope: where countries and stakeholders act together, nature can recover, as the comeback of bluefin tuna shows. The Baltic Sea already has strong foundations for the same in decades of regional cooperation through HELCOM and new EU legal requirements to restore nature. Patrick Child, Deputy Director-General for DG Environment at the European Commission , built on this in his keynote. He described restoring the Baltic Sea as a regional necessity rather than a local ambition, and stressed that it requires cooperation between different authorities – which is exactly where HELCOM provides added value. Additionally, he emphasized that we must move away from isolated action and fragmented recovery towards regional measures, enabling genuine recovery of the sea.
By CCB • November 6, 2026
Nearly 20 years after Baltic Sea countries first agreed in Poland on a plan to save a degrading Baltic Sea, ministers met on Wednesday in Warsaw for the 2026 HELCOM Ministerial Meeting. At the halfway point of the 2021 Baltic Sea Action Plan (BSAP) [1] most actions remain only partially accomplished, and the Baltic Sea is still in a poor state [2] . WWF and Coalition Clean Baltic (CCB) are deeply disappointed that the meeting concluded without the adoption of a Ministerial Declaration. Without a clear acceleration in implementation, the 2030 targets risk being missed – just as many of the 2021 targets were. While ministers voiced their support for continued regional cooperation through HELCOM, regional agreements only help the sea once countries carry them out – and every country must play its part. The meeting reviewed progress in implementing the BSAP’s 199 actions but concluded without adoption of the anticipated Warsaw Ministerial Declaration. A ministerial declaration would have provided an important political signal on how countries intend to accelerate implementation of the BSAP and shape regional cooperation beyond 2030 [3]. The absence of a declaration makes delivery of existing commitments even more important. Commitments must be matched by action The first Baltic Sea Action Plan was adopted in Kraków in November 2007, with the goal of a healthy Baltic Sea by 2021. That goal was not reached: by 2021, only around a quarter of the plan’s national actions had been implemented by all countries [4]. Half-way through the implementation of the updated action plan – the 2021 BSAP, the majority of actions are still only partially accomplished [5]. With just over four years left until 2030, the region is on track to repeat history. Most BSAP actions are carried out nationally, and the responsibility for delivering them lies with each Contracting Party. Warsaw must not become another stop on the same road – this time, commitments must be matched by delivery. Strengthening the implementation of the BSAP is a priority of the new Polish presidency of HELCOM [6].